How to handle

404 pages

properly for optimal SEO

  • SEO
  • 404 pages: how to handle them properly for SEO

Stop redirecting all 404 error pages to your homepage

Many people believe all 404 error pages should be redirected to the homepage. Google advises against this practice, and there are several good reasons to follow that advice.

A 404 error page has a clear job: it shows both users and search engines that a specific URL has been removed or is unavailable.

When you redirect all of them to the homepage, you create confusion that can harm both the user experience and your visibility in search results.

Why 404 redirects to the homepage hurt SEO

Martin Splitt, Developer Advocate at Google, addressed the topic in an episode of “SEO Office Hours Shorts” in 2025. He says the practice annoys users and disrupts search engine crawlers in several ways:

Confuses crawlers

When Google’s crawlers meet a 404 that is forwarded to the homepage, it can create inefficient loops in crawling.

Sends the wrong signals

A 404 error page tells search engines the content is missing. When you redirect to the homepage, the search engine gets conflicting signals. Google may treat such redirects as so-called soft 404 errors.

Weakens user trust

Users who follow a link to specific content become frustrated when they unexpectedly land on the homepage without an explanation.

How to handle 404 error pages correctly

Instead of sending all 404 error pages to the homepage, follow three tips.

1. Redirect when the content has moved

If the content has moved to a new URL, create a specific 301 redirect to the new address. That gives both users and search engines a coherent experience.

For example: when the product page “winter-jacket-2025” has become “winter-jacket-2026,” redirect the old URL straight to the new product page.

2. Keep the 404 status when the content is actually gone

If the content is gone for good and has no direct replacement, keeping the 404 status is the right choice. It is the most honest message to both users and search engines.

3. Offer useful alternatives on the 404 page

- Search function

- Links to popular or related pages

- Clear navigation back to the main sections

- An explanation of what has happened

This lets the user find what they are looking for without being forced to the homepage.

A practical approach for larger websites

On websites with many content changes, handling every 404 error manually takes time. Work through it like this:

  • Analyze 404 traffic: Use Google Analytics or Search Console to see which 404 errors get the most traffic.

  • Prioritize high-traffic URLs: Create specific redirects first for the URLs that still get a lot of traffic.

  • Categorize the 404 errors: Group them by content type (products, articles, categories), and create a redirect strategy for each group.

  • Create an informative 404 page: Where a specific redirect is ruled out, the 404 page should give meaningful guidance.

Effective social media channel strategy

Honesty lasts longest

The best advice is to be honest with both users and search engines. Use the right HTTP status code, and tell the user what happened to the content they were looking for. Disguising missing content with a redirect to the homepage works poorly.

This way you respect both user intent and search engine guidelines, and your website becomes more trustworthy over time.

Rule of thumb: Redirect only to content that is equally relevant. If such content is missing, keep the 404 status and build a helpful error page.

Source: Search Engine Journal, “Google’s Martin Splitt Warns Against Redirecting 404s To Homepage” (2025).

Read more in the glossary about 301 redirect, 404 error and crawling.

Questions and answers about 404 pages

  • Should I redirect all 404 pages to the homepage?

    No. Google’s Martin Splitt advises against it because it confuses crawlers and users. Google may treat such redirects as soft 404 errors.

  • When should I use a 301 redirect?

    Use a 301 redirect when the content has moved to a new URL. Point the old address straight to the new page with equivalent content.

  • When should I keep the 404 status?

    Keep the 404 status when the content is gone for good and has no direct replacement. It is the most honest message to both users and search engines.

  • What should a good 404 page contain?

    Give the user a search function, links to popular or related pages, clear navigation to the main sections and an explanation of what has happened.

  • How do I handle many 404 errors on a large website?

    Analyze the traffic to the 404 pages, and prioritize the URLs that still get a lot of traffic. Group the errors by content type, and create a redirect strategy for each group.

Want to know more?

Jan Ove Årsæther

Strategidirektør, seniorrådgiver

janove@maverix.no+47 414 43 611

Marius Vestlien Hansen

SEO & SEM Lead

marius@maverix.no+47 948 80 177

What can we do for you?

Maverix is a leading agency in strategy, technology, advertising and design that creates growth with you and your products and services.