Golden glamour in a surreal studio

Surfer SEO

An overrated tool?

  • SEO
  • Surfer SEO and Ahrefs: why do they give different scores?

When we optimize content, different tools often give very different assessments of the same text.

Here I explain why, and what it means for you if you work with SEO.

By Marius Vestlien Hansen
SEO/SEM Lead, Maverix
marius@maverix.no

How the tools work

Ahrefs is an SEO platform with a large database built up over many years. In our experience, Ahrefs checks whether the text answers what people are wondering about, whether it hangs together naturally and whether it covers the topic thoroughly enough.

Read more: 96.55 percent of all content gets zero organic traffic from Google

Surfer SEO analyzes the pages that rank highest for your keyword and gives a Content Score based on factors such as related terms, length and structure. The tool counts terms and compares your text directly with the competition. Newer versions also have an AI Search Score and a built-in AI writer. The score can rise without the text getting better for the reader.

The big gap

In our test of one article, the text scored 69 points in Ahrefs and 51 in Surfer. The gap shows that the tools measure different things: Ahrefs assesses topic coverage and coherence, while Surfer compares terms and structure with the competition. Google’s language models, such as BERT and MUM, emphasize context and user intent. Answering the reader’s question well therefore carries more weight than a high score.

Read more

Websites for XXL and Adams Matkasse on an iMac, tablet and phone in a department store

14 SEO myths to stop believing in 2026

The challenge with Surfer

My concern is that a score can lead us in the wrong direction. When the tool rewards more and more terms, it is easy to end up with a text that sounds unnatural. That is called keyword stuffing, and Google’s spam policies prohibit it. At a time when AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and AIO (AI Optimization) are becoming ever more important, a text written for the score can work against its purpose.

The strength of Ahrefs

Ahrefs bases its analyses on a lot of data from the search results. In our experience, its recommendations often match what Google rewards. The tool suits modern SEO practice, where the focus is on answering the real questions people ask.

How should you use the tools?

My recommendation is to choose one of the big SEO tools, such as Ahrefs or SEMrush.

- Start with Ahrefs’ “Keywords Explorer” to find out what people actually search for and which questions they have.

- Use Ahrefs’ “Content Helper” as a technical checklist for structure and basic optimization.

- Read the text aloud: if it sounds unnatural, it probably is.

The tools are aids for you as a writer. Surfer SEO can show which terms the competition covers, and Ahrefs can show which questions people ask. We use Ahrefs ourselves every day. What decides the outcome is how useful the content is for the reader.

Read more

Stylish popcorn party with a dog

Link building in 2026: how to build links that work

Sources: Surfer SEO, Content Editor overview and Google Search Central, spam policies (keyword stuffing).

Read more in the glossary about keywords, keyword research and AEO.

Questions and answers about Surfer SEO and Ahrefs

  • Is Surfer SEO a good tool?

    Surfer SEO analyzes the pages that rank highest for a keyword and gives a Content Score based on factors such as terms, length and structure. It is useful as input, but a high score does not guarantee a better text for the reader.

  • Why do Surfer and Ahrefs give different scores to the same text?

    The tools measure different things. Surfer compares terms and structure with the competition, while Ahrefs assesses topic coverage and coherence. In our test, the same article scored 69 points in Ahrefs and 51 in Surfer.

  • What is keyword stuffing?

    Keyword stuffing means inserting keywords so often that the text sounds unnatural. Google’s spam policies prohibit it.

  • How should I use SEO tools?

    Use the tools as aids. Start with the Ahrefs “Keywords Explorer” to find what people search for, and use “Content Helper” as a checklist for structure. Read the text aloud, and change it if it sounds unnatural.

  • Which SEO tool should I choose?

    Choose one of the big SEO tools, such as Ahrefs or SEMrush. We use Ahrefs ourselves every day, but the most important thing is that the content is useful for the reader.

Want to know more?

Jan Ove Årsæther

Strategidirektør, seniorrådgiver

janove@maverix.no+47 414 43 611

Marius Vestlien Hansen

SEO & SEM Lead

marius@maverix.no+47 948 80 177

What can we do for you?

Maverix is a leading agency in strategy, technology, advertising and design that creates growth with you and your products and services.